Diversity in SFF
I’ve been very much appreciating the #DiversityInSFF conversation on Twitter for the past week.
As in any such conversation, there have been a few trolls and some attempts to derail, not to mention some at-times tacky self-promotion, but overall I think it’s been a good discussion.
I haven’t read every single Tweet, but I think I’ve come pretty close. Here are some of the highlights I remember:
- Tor.com added the following to their submission guidelines, “We want our stories to represent the full diversity of speculative fiction, and encourage submissions by writers from underrepresented populations.”
- The Guardian published an article titled, “It’s time for science fiction to face up to discrimination,” arguing that SF/F has to stop ignoring the diversity of our own world. While there were some problematic aspects to the article (quoting only male authors), it’s nice to see the discussion getting picked up by a major news outlet. (The comments, on the other hand, are often cringeworthy.)
- Lightspeed Magazine announced a “Women Destroying SF” issue. I don’t know if this was directly in response to the #DiversityInSFF conversation, but either way, I love that they’re taking shots at the “Oh no, girl cooties are destroying SF!!!” nonsense.
- Mary Robinette Kowal put together a survey asking Who are the fans of speculative fiction?
- Romantic Times posted an article about 5 Diverse SFF Novels You Should Read. (I have mixed feelings about my own novel being included in that list.)
- People shared resources for encouraging and increasing diversity in the genre, including:
- The Carl Brandon Awards, which I believe are still accepting nominations.
- Diversity in YA is doing a book giveaway that y’all should totally go enter.
- Disability in Kidlit shared a discussion about contributors’ least favorite disability tropes.
- Writing the Other, by Nisi Shawl and Cynthia Ward.
- Polenth Blake posted a list of 100 Diverse Speculative Authors, “diverse in various ways including (but not limited to) sex, gender, class, sexuality, race, religion, country of origin, disability and neurotypicality.”
- @POCKickstarter – “Trying to help people of color jumpstart their Kickstarter ideas.”
There was much more, including discussion of panel parity, accessibility issues, gender, sexual orientation, DC’s ongoing failures when it comes to diversity in comics, movies, small press vs. large, the need for translated fiction, and so on. I’ve also seen the discussion picked up elsewhere.
Along related lines, Rose Lemberg has started an #accessiblecons conversation on Twitter, talking about how to make conventions more accessible (an ongoing problem in fandom).
Will Twitter hashtags fix the world? Obviously not. But I strongly believe talking about problems, and more importantly, listening to the people pointing out those problems, is the first step to solving them. There are editors and agents who changed their guidelines as a result of this conversation. Authors reconsidered their own choices. Readers and viewers of SFF who took another look at their preferences and decided to check out something new.
If you’re on Twitter, I strongly recommend reading through some of the #DiversityInSFF conversation. A fair amount of it is 101-level, but in my opinion, there’s some very good stuff.
September 9, 2013 @ 9:56 am
Hi Jim! Love the round-up, and thanks so much for linking to Disability in Kidlit. I love all the responses to that discussion post so much and I’m always happy to see it being shared.
Just a note, though: the name of the site is *Disability* in Kidlit, not *Diversity* in Kidlit.
Jim C. Hines
September 9, 2013 @ 10:21 am
Thank you, Corinne! Fixed now.
September 9, 2013 @ 12:49 pm
The GeekFeminism Wiki has been building information on making conferences and conventions (both technical, fan, or whatever) more accessible: http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Accessibility_best_practices
September 9, 2013 @ 12:51 pm
Thanks for the recap. I will definitely be sharing some of those links! And grats for making it to the Romantic Times list!
The characters in the September series and #DiversityinSFF | Jack Lusted
September 10, 2013 @ 5:09 pm
[…] the #DiversityinSFF conversation happening on twitter, nicely summarised by Jim C. Hines here, I thought I would post my thoughts on the subject and what I’m doing about […]
October 23, 2013 @ 9:27 pm
A jumping in point for finding faith based or faith exploring spec fic. Certainly an underrepresented group in mainstream sci fi. http://www.speculativefaith.com/